Skip to main content

DVD review | The Phantom of the Opera | A new documentary unmasks the iconic masterpiece


Phantom of the Opera – Unmasking the Masterpiece is a 105-minute long visual retrospective of the famed 1910 Gaston Leroux novel (opens in new tab), which has spawned numerous film, stage and television adaptations; turned the character of the Opera ghost into one of the most recognisable and iconic images in popular culture; and influenced famous horror films from House of Wax to The Abominable Dr Phibes and The Phantom of the Paradise.

Focusing on the three classic film versions in which Lon Chaney (opens in new tab), Claude Rains (opens in new tab) and Herbert Lom (opens in new tab) each gave their own distinctive portrayal of the Phantom - in 1925, 1943 and 1962 respectively, this labour of love from Cortlandt Hull, the owner of The Witch’s Dungeon (opens in new tab) classic horror movie museum in Connecticut, features interviews with a 103-year-old Carla Laemmle (opens in new tab), the only surviving cast member of the 1925 film, and Ron Chaney (opens in new tab), the great grandson of Lon Chaney.

Fleshing out the retrospective, famed make-up artist Tom Savini talks about how he was inspired by Chaney, while film historians Michael Blake, Steve Haberman and Daniel Roebuck trace the making-of the three films, highlight the differences in the 1929 international version, and profile James Cagney’s 1957 Lon Chaney biopic, The Man of a Thousand Faces (opens in new tab). The anecdotes told here will certainly thrill classic film buffs (who knew set designer Charles Gemora (opens in new tab) was also one of the famed gorilla suit actors of the golden age of cinema?) and there’s a peek inside Chaney’s famous make-up box - without doubt the important artefact in the history of film make-up.

Phantom of the Opera: Unmasking a Masterpiece

Almost 1000 rare movie posters and photos have been carefully restored to accompany the interviews, plus there’s a tour of the actual opera set on soundstage 28 (opens in new tab) of the Universal Studios lot which was built for the original 1925 film, and is today the oldest standing set in Hollywood. Bringing the Phantom's legacy up to date, Hugh Panaro (opens in new tab), the current Broadway star of Andrew Lloyd Webber’s musical (opens in new tab), closes the proceedings with a look at the secrets and makeup used on the stage version, which is celebrating its 25th year.

Phantom of the Opera: Unmasking the Masterpiece is available on DVD (NTSC only) (click here to order from Amazon (opens in new tab)).

For a full review of the BFI's newly-restored release of The Phantom of the Opera on Blu-ray, check out Pete's review (CLICK HERE (opens in new tab)).