Survivor Claire's departure has fans raging as a woman is axed again
On Survivor, Claire's lack of challenge participation made her an easy target, and fans aren't happy about it
Yes, yet another woman has been voted off Survivor: Claire sitting out of an immunity challenge proved to be the kiss of death for the 25-year-old tech investor, as her Soka tribemates used her absence to fix a target on her back.
At the beginning of Wednesday's episode of Survivor season 44, it looked as though the Soka clan would be setting their sights on this season's lovebirds, Matt and Frannie. "Matt and Frannie go off alone all the time, they're like two nerdy people that just like to nerd out," Claire said. "It's a huge liability for four other people in the tribe to be looking and saying, 'Oh those two, they're a duo.'"
However, things were looking up for the twosome when Matt seemingly discovered the key to the birdcage and thus took possession of the immunity idol... except it was a fake that Danny, who had found the real one, had hidden in plain sight to get his tribemates off his tail. However, nobody but Danny knew that it was a dummy idol, and thus dubbed Matt and Frannie "no longer easy targets."
When it came to immunity challenge time, however, Claire proved an easy mark after choosing to sit out of competing for the third time, reasoning that it was in the best interest of the tribe. Ratu and Tika win immunity, sending Soka to the Tribal Council for the first time this season.
"I feel terrible because I love Claire...but you do have to form a camaraderie in these challenges," Danny said. "Who hasn't done any challenges and who doesn't seem like they're gonna be useful in challenges?"
Despite Claire trying to turn Heidi against "cagey" Josh to vote him out instead and using her Shot in the Dark during the Tribal Council, Claire ends up being the fourth person eliminated from the Survivor season 44 cast—much to fans' chagrin.
That's because, other than the early medical evacuation of competitor Bruce Perreault, so far this season's "boot order"—the list of tribemates who have been eliminated each episode—has followed a troubling trend from Survivor season 43: the first players voted out are women, with Claire Rafson joining Maddy Pomilla and Helen Li.
Get the What to Watch Newsletter
The latest updates, reviews and unmissable series to watch and more!
Survivor's Claire is the latest in a 'tragic' trend, fans say:
Viewers took to Twitter to discuss the worrying trend, with many criticizing the season's three-tribe structure for making it easy to target the women players ("queen after queen robbed!" one user wrote) and others hoping that Claire would be able to return in a future season:
Me looking at this boot order. #Survivor44 pic.twitter.com/iKg3h5DfFUMarch 16, 2023
i’m loving this season but hating this boot order but i’ll literally be so sad no matter who goes home because i love every single one of them😭😭😭 #Survivor44March 16, 2023
I have been upset with every elimination on #Survivor44 so far. This boot order is NOT it! 😭😭😭March 16, 2023
This boot order its already giving survivor 43.... #survivor #Survivor44 pic.twitter.com/tb2lyTMNDbMarch 16, 2023
You cannot tell me production loves this boot order 😭 #Survivor44March 16, 2023
And they said this season is good, then wtf is this boot order then? #survivor #Survivor44 pic.twitter.com/0FRsMe3HytMarch 16, 2023
NOOOO not claire!!! this boot order is horrific 😭😭😭 queen after queen robbed #Survivor44March 16, 2023
when the newest new era twist is actually that the first three boots “voted out” are actually the final 3 and everyone else becomes the jury 😍😍😍😍😍 let me be delusional 😍😍😍 #Survivor44March 16, 2023
the first 3 boots being women trend needs to stop 😭🤚 #survivor44 pic.twitter.com/tg5T37WEPQMarch 16, 2023
The anger about the recent early boot orders is 1. totally warranted and 2. best directed (by far) at the producers insisting the first 90% of every single challenge be a massive obstacle course/weightlifting combo. Insane, unfair, and full-blown creatively bankrupt. #SurvivorMarch 16, 2023
this season is stacking up to be pretty good but the boot order is unforgivable. we really need a season of all pre-jurors to give maddy and claire another shot 😭 #survivorMarch 16, 2023
IM SO SICK I HATE THIS BOOT ORDER. #Survivor pic.twitter.com/9dRN90xOvqMarch 16, 2023
This boot order is really flopping… #survivor44 pic.twitter.com/vH3mJdttVvMarch 16, 2023
Well, this boot order sucks. When are we gonna stop voting out women because they are “weak”? #Survivor44March 16, 2023
THIS BOOT ORDER HAS BEEN TRAGIC IF IM HONEST #survivor44March 16, 2023
Jeff Probst insisting on this new format that results in the same boot order every time #Survivor pic.twitter.com/U7RJSnFhGBMarch 16, 2023
THATS MY WINNER PICK Y'ALL JUST SENT HOMEMarch 16, 2023
Christina Izzo is the Deputy Editor of My Imperfect Life. More generally, she is a writer-editor covering food and drink, travel, lifestyle and culture in New York City. She was previously the Features Editor at Rachael Ray In Season and Reveal, as well as the Food & Drink Editor and chief restaurant critic at Time Out New York.
When she’s not doing all that, she can probably be found eating cheese somewhere.