EastEnders fans spot HUGE plot hole as the Beales return to Walford!

EastEnders - the Beales return to Albert Square
(Image credit: BBC)

EastEnders fans were thrilled to see the return of the Beale family in yesterday's action-packed double episode.

But it wasn't long before the eagle-eyed viewers had spotted an enormous plot hole because something - or rather someone - very important had been forgotten.

Cindy's other daughter, Cindy Jr!

Bobby Beale is on a mission

Bobby was worried that Kathy had put the chippy up for sale (Image credit: BBC)

In Albert Square, things were going wrong for Bobby Beale and his crush Anna Knight.

Bobby was distraught after hearing his newlywed mum, Kathy Cotton, had put the chip shop up for sale and was trying to get in touch with his brother, Peter.

Meanwhile, Anna had been given (grudging) approval by her family to try calling her mum, Rose Knight.

Ian Beale argues with son Peter

Ian tried to talk Peter out of leaving France. (Image credit: BBC)

Or Cindy Beale as she's better known.

Peter wanted to go home after he got Bobby's message, but Ian - who knew the Knights are in Walford - desperately tried to talk him out of it.

Later, Peter spotted Anna's message on Cindy's phone, starting 'Mum'. Intrigued, he read the text - and then listened to her voicemail.

Ian was fuming and told him not to upset his mother. But Peter - whose twin sister Lucy was murdered (by Bobby!) - pointed out he had lost one sister, and now he had two more he wanted to meet.

Peter Beale looks worried

Peter tries to remember how many siblings he's got. (Image credit: BBC)

In the whole conversation, though, no one mentioned Peter's other sister, Cindy Williams - AKA Cindy Jr. She lived in Albert Square from 2013 until 2014 and was part of the family when poor Lucy was murdered in 2015.

She's not Ian's daughter, but she is most definitely Cindy's - in fact, her mother was said to have died in childbirth and Cindy Jr was brought up by her auntie Gina.

Peter knows Cindy Jr well - so does Ian - though Cindy Beale has presumably never met her daughter since she gave her up at birth.

Fans took to social media to share their bewilderment at poor Cindy Jr being forgotten.

"Peter has two more sisters?" questioned one confused viewer. "Surely, he means three - or has he forgotten about Cindy Jr?"

Another viewer said: "What about the other daughter?" Adding: "Has everyone forgotten about her?"

One fan was more direct about Cindy Jr's absence.

"This story makes no sense without including her," the viewer pointed out. "Bring her back, get a recast, I don't care."

Mimi Keene as Cindy Williams Jr in EastEnders.

Could Cindy Jr be back? (Image credit: BBC)

Cindy Jr's currently in Germany with her boyfriend Liam Butcher, his sister Tiffany Butcher-Baker and her husband Keegan. Plus Liam's dad Ricky and his niece, Scarlet.

While Cindy's daughter Beth, lives in Milton Keynes with her dad TJ Spraggan, his dad Terry and his stepmum - Bianca Jackson.

So Cindy's got LOADS of links to the Square even before you consider her mum coming back from the dead and two new sisters for her to meet.

There is a tiny bit of hope for Cindy Jr fans.

Michelle Collins, who plays Cindy Beale, was asked about the possibility of two Cindys returning to the Square and said: "Possibly, who knows!"

Cindy Jr was played by Mimi Keene, who later shot to fame starring in the Netflix show Sex Education.

Could she be tempted back to Walford? Even for a short time?

We're keeping our fingers crossed!

EastEnders usually airs Monday to Thursday at 7.30pm on BBC One and BBC iPlayer. Check our TV Guide for more information.

Kerry Barrett
Freelance writer

Kerry is a writer, author and editor with a lifelong love of the soaps, a passion for TV drama of all kinds, and an obsessive devotion to Strictly Come Dancing. 

She was features editor of All About Soap magazine for more than a decade, covering every bit of excitement from all the UK soaps and the Aussies and still writes about all the juiciest gossip from the Street, the Square and the Dales whenever she can.

Kerry’s also an author of historical fiction, and her two jobs collided when she got the chance to write two novels based on Emmerdale, and the Sugden, Tate and Dingle families, during WW2.