As a Hallmark movie expert, these are the seven Hallmark Channel movies Travis Kelce should watch first

Ryan Paevey, Pascale Hutton in Fourth Down and Love
Ryan Paevey and Pascale Hutton in Fourth Down and Love (Image credit: Hallmark Media/Photographer: Allister Foster)

Now that Kansas City Chiefs' Travis Kelce has added "Hallmarkie" to his impressive resume, we thought we would help the Chiefs standout with a list of our favorite Hallmark Channel movies that shouldn't be missed. 

We've pulled together an assortment of Hallmark Channel sports-themed movies and a few gems that are a great starting point for newly dabbling Hallmarkies like Travis Kelce or longtime fans looking for their next feel-good movie binge.

Fourth Down and Love

Ryan Paevey and Pascale Hutton in Fourth Down and Love

Ryan Paevey and Pascale Hutton in Fourth Down and Love (Image credit: Hallmark Media/Photographer: Allister Foster)

Of course we had to have a football movie in the mix and Fourth Down and Love, featuring Ryan Paevey and Pascale Hutton, is a great way to kick off a movie marathon. Paevey is a pro football player who reconnects with his former college sweetheart, Hutton, during her daughter's flag football game. 

Checkin' It Twice

Kevin McGarry in Checkin' It Twice

Kevin McGarry in Checkin' It Twice (Image credit: Hallmark Media/Photographer: Paulina Stevens)

As a winter sport, hockey is the perfect sport to be featured in a Christmas movie. Checkin' It Twice combines the thrill of the game with a heartwarming story of a journeyman hockey player (Kevin McGarry) who gets traded to a small town hockey team. Kim Matula plays a real estate agent who heads home for the holidays to find the hockey player she met at the airport is staying in her family's rental. 

The Nine Lives of Christmas

Brandon Routh, Kimberley Sustad in The Nine Lives of Christmas

Brandon Routh and Kimberley Sustad in The Nine Lives of Christmas (Image credit: Crown Media United States, LLC/Photographer: Katie Yu)

There are plenty of Hallmark Channel movies about dogs, but The Nine Lives of Christmas stands out for a number of reasons, including the adorable connection between stars Kimberley Sustad and Brandon Routh and their feline friends. Routh is a firefighter who finds a cat and Sustad is the vet tech who helps him navigate life as a new Cat Dad.

The Nine Lives of Christmas is a Hallmark classic, beloved by Hallmarkies everywhere. The cat theme draws a fun Taylor Swift connection: during the 2023-2024 NFL season, Kelce's Chiefs faced the Buffalo Bills and the Chiefs' win came from a missed Bills field goal that would have tied the game. Bills kicker Tyler Bass received hateful backlash so Swifties stepped in and sent donations to the Ten Lives Club, a Buffalo cat rescue where Bass, a cat lover, serves as an ambassador. Thanks to the Swifties' support, the rescue received over $260,000 in donations on Bass' behalf. 

And if you're looking for more feline fun, Routh and Sustad reunited for a sequel, The Nine Kittens of Christmas

Hearts in the Game

Marco Grazzini, Darcy Laurie, Erin Cahill in Hearts in the Game

Marco Grazzini, Darcy Laurie and Erin Cahill in Hearts in the Game (Image credit: Hallmark Media/Photographer: Allister Foster)

There's nothing like a baseball romance, except when the baseball romance comes from the good folks at Hallmark. In Hearts in the Game, Erin Cahill plays a famed publicist known for getting her clients out of the toughest situations. She's hired to work with a Mets pitcher (Marco Grazzini) who is going through some challenges. When they meet she realizes that they'd been high school sweethearts, which leads to some surprising discoveries.

Love on the Right Course

Ashley Newbrough in Love on the Right Course

Ashley Newbrough in Love on the Right Course (Image credit: Hallmark Media/Photographer: Courtesy Leif Films Inc.)

Love on the Right Course reunites Hallmark Channel regulars Ashley Newbrough and Marcus Rosner in a charming movie about a pro golfer (Newbrough) who returns home to Budapest to figure out her future in the sport she has played her whole life. She meets another pro golfer, Rosner, who helps her remember what she loves about golf while figuring out what she wants in life and love.

Game, Set, Love

Richard Harmon, Davida Williams in Game, Set, Love

Richard Harmon and Davida Williams in Game, Set, Love (Image credit: Crown Media United States LLC/Photographer: Allister Foster)

Training for a mixed doubles tournament brings a former tennis pro (Davida Williams) together with the "bad boy" of tennis in Game, Set, Love. While they might not see eye to eye about tennis or training, as they work together they soon discover they have more in common than they realized. 

Shifting Gears

Tyler Hynes, Katherine Barrell in Shifting Gears

Tyler Hynes and Katherine Barrell in Shifting Gears (Image credit: Hallmark Media/Photographer: Albert Camicioli)

Car lovers can also find movies they love on Hallmark Channel. In Shifting Gears, Katherine Barrell plays a mechanic hired to be part of a car restoration show. She's shocked to find that her ex-boyfriend, played by Tyler Hynes, is her competition. The two former flames are forced to work together, but will love give their spark plugs a jump start?


Hallmark Channel is included in many cable TV packages, but if you've cut the cord there are a few other options to help you watch. Hallmark Channel now has a partnership with Peacock so you can watch new movies on the streaming platform with a subscription.

You can also access Hallmark Channel via Philo, Sling TV, Frndly TV, Hulu with Live TV, YouTube TV and Fubo. While Hallmark Movies Now is the network's streaming arm, you cannot access new movies right away, so if you're looking to watch new Hallmark Channel originals you'll need access to the channel.

Sarabeth Pollock
Editorial Content Producer

 

Sarabeth joined the What to Watch team in May 2022. An avid TV and movie fan, her perennial favorites are The Walking Dead, American Horror Story, true crime documentaries on Netflix and anything from Passionflix. You’ve Got Mail, Ocean's Eleven and Signs are movies that she can watch all day long. She's also a huge baseball fan, and hockey is a new favorite.  

When she's not working, Sarabeth hosts the My Nights Are Booked Podcast and a blog dedicated to books and interviews with authors and actors. She also published her first novel, Once Upon an Interview, in 2022.